There is something your not saying...
Like maybe saying "Well I did log on once through my laptop to my phone's account"... Then yes... They can see that Computer connecting to two different accounts... and flag you for it... and always keep a record of it.
I just find it particular coincidences that they called you out on something that is true.
A webmaster... or mod... depending on their access to the Webserver can see more things than you can believe.
Heres a small list:
Your Computer Name
Your UserName on that Computer Name
Your WAN IP... of Course... a Given.
Your Browser... make and version.
Here is what they are called actually:
HTTP_USER_AGENT - Your Browser
HTTPS - Session ID
REMOTE_ADDR - Your IP Address
REMOTE_HOST - Your Computer Name
REMOTE_PORT - Your connecting port
REMOTE_USER - Your Username on that Computer
REDIRECT_REMOTE_USER - If you was redirected.. Username who redirected you.